Last academic year, having discovered mindfulness myself and done a 4-week Futurelearn course (Mindfulness for Wellbeing and Peak Performance – next starting on 7th October and highly recommended!), I decided to experiment with using a mindfulness meditation with my foundation class students in their second and third terms. I finished the course sometime around the end of their first term, so the beginning of term two seemed the logical time to jump in, if I was going to do it.
As it was the first time for me to try something like this with students, I was very nervous about it BUT my belief in the potential benefits for them gave me the courage to try. Just prior to the first lesson of term two, I adapted the shortest mindfulness meditation from the Futurelearn course (the “Comma” – so called as you can use it to draw breath briefly and reset throughout the day) so that linguistically it was more accessible to my students. I didn’t have to make many changes as I had a high level group, but with lower level students I would make further adaptations/simplifications. In the first lesson of term, I distributed print-outs of the meditation and asked students to look at it and discuss these questions in pairs:
What is this? What is it for?
Why do you think it is called “Comma”?
Have you used anything like this before?
What could be the benefits for using it on a regular basis?
The “Mindfulness meditation: Comma” was obviously a give-away with regards to the what, and being Chinese students the concept of meditation was familiar to them. Once they had discussed the questions in pairs, we discussed them as a whole class. The fourth question is particularly important, as by talking about the potential benefits, you create some buy-in for when you then go on to say that the plan is to use this meditation at the start of each class.
What are the benefits?
- It allows students to “arrive” in the lesson
- It helps them focus their minds into the present, letting go of distractions such as worries generated by the previous lesson, content of conversations with friends, worry about various assignments, arguments they might have recently with friends/family – basically anything that isn’t happening now.
However, I will let the students speak for themselves. At the end of the two terms, having been observed teaching by my line manager who was impressed by the students’ response to the meditation, I gave them a little questionnaire to complete. There were four questions – one about the meditation, one about the listening logs we used at the start of one lesson per week (after the meditation), and then one about what they thought was good about AES (Academic English Skills) classes and one about what they thought would make AES classes better.
100% of them responded positively to the question about meditation (“For terms 2 and 3 we started every AES lesson with a short (2 minute) meditation. I think this was good/not good to do because…”). Here are their sentence completions:
I think this was good to do because…
it helps us to relax ourselves, and get our minds back to AES class.
It helps to concentrate on lesson better, feels great.
It was able to clear the mind and get ready to start the lesson in refreshing feelings.
It helps me relax after climbing up 7 floors. It helps me to concentrate easily. It could take up some lesson time.
I can pay attention for my AES lesson.
It made us focus better in the class.
This was a very good thing to as it allowed us to focus more.
It can clear my mind and help me focus on the tasks and activities.
It could help me stop thinking other subject’s work and help me be more focus in class.
During this section, I can relax myself before the start of the lesson.
It helped me concentrate better in class. I was able to clear my mind of all the unwanted thoughts and focus better. Relax too.
One student was absent. Obviously the clear themes running through the responses are about focus/concentration and relaxation. You might be thinking “but I don’t want my students to relax in my class, I want them to work hard!”. I think though that the sense of “relax” here is in opposition to stress. The students where I work are under an immense amount of pressure, and research shows that when stress goes beyond a certain amount, performance and productivity drop. So, if my students are worrying about all the assignments and deadlines, and what they didn’t understand in the class they had before AES etc etc, they aren’t going to be receptive to what I teach them as they will be distracted by stressing and worrying. Additionally, experience shows that when they are relaxed and engaged (the two are not mutually exclusive), they perform well in class and evidence of their learning can be seen in their assignments. As for the one who said “it can take up some lesson time” – these students have hours and hours of classes a day and I saw them 4-6 (last slot) on a Monday (all three terms), 2-4 on a Wednesday (term 1+2) 3-5 on a Tuesday (term 3) and 1330-1430 on a Friday so particularly for those late afternoon slots, it’s tough on them, so it’s not surprising they welcomed the chance to breathe for a couple of minutes. The benefits yielded in terms of focus were, to my mind, well worth those minutes.
I’m really pleased with the results of my little experiment and this academic year plan to continue my use of the guided meditation at the start of each class. (Basically, I lead the meditation, which begins “Now, with your body balanced in the chair and your eyes gently closed”. The first time you do it, the students might be a bit giggly, looking at classmates with one eye etc but very soon it becomes routine and they do it very calmly.) I will also be leading a short session with my colleagues next week, to share this idea with them so that they can also have a go using it with their students if they want to. I’m planning to get them to do the meditation just as I would do it with my students so that they have a feel for what it is like. Here is a link to the unadapted version of the meditation that I used, by Dr Craig Hassad. It is the first recording in the list – One minute comma.
Do you do any kind of meditation with your students? How has it worked for you/them?
If you are interested in the science behind mindfulness and learning, I recommend this book:
Finally, for those who want to know a bit more about Mindfulness, here is a TED Talk about it by Dr Richard Chambers:
Pingback: First class of the year – Lizzie Pinard
Pingback: Using Mindfulness with Students Q&A – Lizzie Pinard
I’d like to recommend the book ‘McMindfulness’ by Ronald Purser (2019, Repeater Books) and / or a recent Guardian article https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2019/apr/16/how-capitalism-captured-the-mindfulness-industry Both or either would offer a useful counter-balance to the book and video you recommend!
Pingback: Scholarship circle: Using mindfulness meditation – Lizzie Pinard
Pingback: TD Workshop – Mindfulness in Teaching – Lizzie Pinard
Pingback: One reason why blogs are useful! – Lizzie Pinard